Travelogue 1074 – 30 December
Rebels Popping
What can we expect in the new year? Shall we read the reports of the firecrackers? There must be a code behind them, even if it’s the cosmic code of chance. In interval or in series or in number or in volume, these explosions from every side must communicate something. Otherwise, what would that signify about fireworks at New Years, that it’s all meaningless mayhem, the handiwork of real children and grown children who are entertained by noise, and not in isolation, but in endless repetition? That if firecrackers were in infinite supply and free, this sub-class of the planet’s most intelligent species would set them off and watch them with every free minute, perhaps for the rest of their lives, trance-like smiles frozen on their washed-out faces? What a disillusionment that would be for optimists about human nature! Better we resolve that the relentless pop-pop-pop tells us about creation and the spirit that enlivens the universe.
Are there portents for the new year in the news? We find that the QAnon prophets were right, after all, that politicians and celebrities were lying, and that they were trafficking in children. It turns out it wasn’t Hillary Clinton or Tom Hanks, however, but in fact members of their own cult. In just the last week or two, we discover a Republican got elected to Congress lying about his education, his work experience, and his ethnicity. He even lied about how and when his mother died. And a high-profile right-wing nutbag, last seen taunting Greta Thunberg with his collection of high-polluting autos, has been detained in Romania in connection with human trafficking, joining QAnon darling Congressman Matt Gaetz in this exclusive club of accusers being accused. Fair enough: when we search for effective insults, we catalogue our own darkest drives. But now, with QAnon freaks taking over the swing vote in Congress, shall we see normalization of their sins?
Is there a silver lining in the cascade of bad news? There might be. Whether we speak about COVID or politics, culture wars or real wars, we see that one persistent human trait prevails: contrariness. As a parent, I have certainly become refamiliarized with this human impulse, the need to rebel against authority. So far, we’ve seen a preponderance of the negative side of that trait, like death threats to poor Dr Fauci for daring to be an expert, or power handed to the likes of Marjorie Taylor-Greene, whose sole qualification is relentless contrariness. But we’ve also seen some rebellion that makes more sense, rebellion against the Trumpian crime-family code, rebellion against Putin’s violent realpolitik, and rebellion against easy cultural codes of virtue offered by either side of the political divide.
There’s been a lot of chatter about the death of democracy. But rebellion and human contrariness are building blocks of democracy. I have been as sensitive as anyone to the fears of growing authoritarianism in world politics. Now I see things a little differently. I think democracy is forever resurgent. Sadly, the darker impulses among us are stronger than we thought, and the work of buttressing democracy is harder than we thought, but we may discover surprising allies in the fight, given that the instinct to rebel is in everyone.